Critiques

This is the first product I recommend to writers paying their own bills. Again, you should use The Bottom Drawer Editor.  It's even more affordable than we are. If your drawer offers little or no help, a critique is the next step. Not only does it provide solid solutions and options, but because you do the rewrite yourself, you learn as you go. DG Writing & Editing critiques also include a phone consultation after the rewrite is delivered. 

Problem

Solution

An Accessible Blueprint

A good critique includes specific notes. The goal is not to criticize, but to offer options. Instead of a simple "This just doesn't work," I verbalize why it doesn't work for me as a reader, then offer a series of "what if" options which will jump-start your rewrite process. DG Writing and Editing critiques also cover mechanics, pointing out problems with grammar, spelling errors and syntax issues. 

 

 

A Second Set of Eyes

If you've been working on your manuscript for the last several months... or years, it is difficult to see the forest for the trees. (This is why your bottom drawer is your best friend.) Even after distancing themselves from the work, many writers still miss crucial flaws. That's why it is vital to have a second set of eyes. You can give the manuscript to someone whose opinion you trust. Some writers even conduct test readings covering a wide range of demographics. The primary problem is people who know you don't always tell the truth. They tend to soften their criticism or offer a well-meaning, "It's great." Now while this might stroke your ego, it does nothing to produce a better product. 

 

 

Learn, Instead of Paying Us the Next Time

 

Most writers who receive a good critique, don't need a second. That's not because the critiques stink... it's because clients learn. That is the goal. I love taking your money, but I want to earn it. Funny, but true. So if you can walk away able to rewrite your next book on your own, DG Writing and Editing has succeeded. All I ask in return is that you recommend the service to other writers. 

Fees and Services

Critique

Critiques average 50 to 70 pages in length and include sections on plot, character and mechanics as well as a chapter-by-chapter analysis referencing specific pages and passages. A standard critique is $475 up to 375 pages. An additional $1.50 is charged for every page after. Each critique also includes a phone consultation to answer any questions or issues you may have once the critique is delivered.

Note:  All critique pricing is based on a standard submission format. Double-spaced text in a 12 point Courier font with one-inch margins all around. Incorrect formatting will result in an additional charge.